When should you sell vs hold your investment property?

Full body barefoot parents and son smiling while sitting on weathered porch step and relaxing outside house on summer day in countryside

There’s this classic question every Brisbane investor asks at some point – “Should I hang onto this place, or is it time to sell?”

I get it. Sometimes it feels like the property is more hassle than it’s worth – constant maintenance, surprise bills, and you only seem to hear from your agent when something’s gone wrong. If you feel like you’re always dipping into your pocket, it’s natural to wonder whether selling would give you a cleaner slate.

Reasons you might hold

  • You’re getting steady, reliable rent and low vacancy.

  • The property’s in a growth pocket with strong tenant demand.

  • Depreciation and tax benefits are still working in your favour.

  • It fits your bigger life plan — a nest egg for retirement, or a place you’d like to keep for your kids when they’re older or at uni.

  • You believe in Brisbane’s long-term story (population, infrastructure, jobs).

Reasons you might sell

  • Cash flow is consistently negative and trending the wrong way.

  • Big-ticket maintenance or upgrades are looming (roof, plumbing, painting, appliances).

  • The suburb’s growth story has likely peaked.

  • Your equity could perform better rolled into a higher-yield or higher-growth asset.

Is negative gearing allowed for Queensland investors?

Yes. Negative gearing is set at the federal level, not by state, so it applies to Queensland investors. If your rental expenses (like loan interest, insurance, and management fees) are greater than the income, the loss can offset your other income for tax purposes — provided the property is genuinely available for rent and you follow ATO rules.

That said, the ATO has been cracking down on incorrect claims, especially around interest deductions, travel costs, and vacant land. It’s worth checking your numbers carefully with your accountant before making a decision.

“Market is high — should I cash in?”

Brisbane’s property market has been strong, with values continuing to rise. It’s tempting to take the win, but the real question is: if you sell, what can you buy for the same money today?

Before you list, think about:

  1. What’s left after costs? Factor in selling fees, marketing, and then stamp duty on your next purchase.

  2. Cash flow on the replacement property: Will the yield be higher, lower, or about the same?

  3. Tax timing: CGT may apply, even if you’re eligible for the 50% discount after 12 months of ownership.

The honest way to decide

Run this as a checklist:

  • 12-month cash flow: rent in vs expenses out.

  • Major repairs & upgrades: what’s coming in the next 3 years?

  • Tax position: negative, neutral, or positive after deductions.

  • Capital gains tax: rough calculation of what you’d owe.

  • Replacement options: what you can actually buy after selling costs and stamp duty.

  • Life plan fit: does keeping the property serve your retirement or family goals, or would selling free you up for something smarter?

Want to dig deeper?

If you’ve been wondering whether to sell or hold onto your property, you’re not alone. Every landlord reaches that crossroads at some point, and the right answer really depends on your numbers, your goals, and your bigger picture.

If you’d like to know more about how to weigh it up, I’m always happy to walk you through the scenarios so you can make a decision with confidence.

References & Resources

Related Posts

Back To Top